One of the things that surprised me most when I entered the popular music college was the colleagues who played very well were professional musicians in search of deeper theoretical knowledge. Their quest was to understand musical structures in a more … structured way.
When I saw the video classroom music is an alien in The Place of Music course in 21st Century Education MOOC, I immediately remembered these colleagues. Especially when Hein says: “And I feel like, the way the pop musicians and the way that I learned, you learn actual songs and then only much later than you decompose them into their smallest constituent parts. Because it takes some sophistication to be able to do that.”
In this same MOOC the reading of this video is suggested. Check it out.
Lucy Green proposed a simple method, in theory, in which “The approach involves the pupil listening to a recording and attempting to play it by ear”. Method based on the way that popular musicians learn until today. More details on Lucy Green method can be seen here
Although music education is evolving to adapt to the new types of music that emerge we can not forget that traditional music teaching has existed for centuries, and if it lasts for so long there are certainly good reasons for that.
An interesting interview with João Camarero that talks about Brazilian music and how the popular universe merges with the traditional.
I believe that it is up to the teacher to know how to get the best of both worlds and adapt their lectures to each class / student. It is up to each one to think and see what his objectives are in teaching and to use the most appropriate method, whether it comes from the popular or traditional school.